The developer was sure the deal had been cancelled.
He had a good reason: the buyers were four months late paying 90% of the apartment price, and the contract itself defined the payment clause as fundamental.
And yet, the Be'er Sheva District Court ordered him to hand over the apartment to them.
The case involved a garden apartment in Sderot that cost NIS 1.4 million. During the delay, the parties met at a gas station, and according to the company's manager, a cancellation was agreed there with a handshake. The buyers claimed they had only agreed to consider it, and asked to see a written document. No such document was ever sent to them.
Three things emerge from the ruling:
1. A fundamental breach does not cancel the contract on its own
"An agreement is not cancelled by itself, even if it was fundamentally breached." Cancellation is an act someone has to take, not a situation that arises on its own.
2. Cancellation must follow the contract's procedure
The contract set out how to cancel: written notice, and ten days for the buyer to complete the payment. The company sent a cancellation notice only after the money had already arrived, meaning after the breach had already been cured.
3. The company's conduct contradicted its cancellation claim
The company kept behaving as if the deal was still in place. It did not return the down payment, did not update the financing bank and did not report to the tax authorities. "It is hard to understand how a matter as significant as cancelling an agreement received no expression whatsoever in writing," the judge wrote.
The buyers did not get off free either. They will pay NIS 118,706 in late payment interest. The court rejected the agreed compensation of 10%, because together with the interest it would have been double compensation.
The takeaway: a fundamental breach gives you a right, but it does not do the work for you. A right of cancellation you did not exercise on time and in the way the contract set out may simply disappear.