Articles & Posts

An oral promise. 10% of the profits. NIS 50 million.

An oral promise. 10% of the profits. NIS 50 million.

And in the end, an order to pay NIS 1 million in legal fees and costs. In the opposite direction.

This week an appeal was filed with the Supreme Court in a dispute between the billionaire Michael Mirilashvili and his cousin, Shabtai Alon. Alon claims it was agreed with him orally that he would receive 10% of the profits of a diamond deal, for his supervision of sorting and polishing at a plant in Russia, and a further 5% as a brokerage fee for bringing the deal in 2009.

The District Court dismissed the claim. The reason was not that an oral agreement is worthless. In Israel a contract can be formed even without a signed document.

It was dismissed because in practice there is no such thing as "only" an oral agreement. There is what was said, and there is everything that happened in the years that followed.

According to the judgment, no written agreement was presented, and neither were any demands for payment. Alon refrained from calling a key witness. The judge even noted that the claim could also have been dismissed as time-barred.

And this is the insight: in a dispute over an oral promise, the court does not ask only what was said. It asks how you conducted yourselves after it was said. Anyone who arrives after years without a single demand letter is asking the judge to believe that he stayed silent in the face of a large sum of money.

It is precisely in family businesses, or between close friends, that this happens most often. Because of the trust, no one asks to put it in writing. Or it feels uncomfortable to turn to a lawyer, because that might sound as if you do not trust the other side. And the most expensive agreement is the one each side remembers differently.

The appeal is still pending, and the Supreme Court has yet to have its say.

All articles and posts