Articles & Posts

13% of the shares. A NIS 6 million claim.

13% of the shares. A NIS 6 million claim.

Most people are sure that voting at a general meeting is a private matter. My shares, my vote, and I vote however I like.

This week the company Tikkun Olam filed a NIS 6 million claim against its large shareholder, who holds only 13%. According to the claim, the company tried to sell its stock exchange shell for NIS 10.5 million. The Israel Securities Authority determined that the deal had to pass by a majority of the shareholders with no personal interest in it, so his vote became decisive. The company claims he conditioned his support on personal demands, the deal came off the agenda, and the shell was eventually sold in insolvency proceedings for only NIS 5 million.

These are the claims of one side. No statement of defense has yet been filed, and the court will decide.

But the question the claim raises is of interest to anyone who holds shares in a company. Section 193 of the Companies Law imposes a duty of fairness not only on a controlling shareholder, but also on a shareholder who knows that his vote is decisive in a vote.

In simple words: if you know that without your vote the decision will not pass, you are no longer voting only for yourself. The law may see you as someone who owes a duty of fairness to the company and to the other shareholders, even if you hold only 13%.

This does not mean that every minority vote is a breach. It means that the question is no longer how many percent you hold, but whether at that moment you know the result depends on you.

All articles and posts