Articles & Posts

A NIS 2.5 million class action that ended in a cheese donation

A motion to certify a class action for NIS 2.5 million.
It ended with a NIS 50,000 cheese donation to a charity.
And the plaintiff and her lawyers received NIS 33,000.

That is the settlement the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court approved in the motion against Meshek Yaakobs cheeses, reported last week.
The claim was that some of the cheeses did not display a price. Yaakobs explained that these are blocks cut at the deli counter, so there is no obligation to mark a price on them. The regulator also supported its position.

And still: full pleadings, four hearings, and in the end a settlement in which the plaintiff's award and the attorneys' fees come to almost 70% of the only monetary component of the settlement.

Why should every business owner care?
Because this is exactly the situation that the amendment to the Class Actions Law, now awaiting final approval in the Knesset, is meant to address. According to the version approved in committee:
• A business with annual turnover of up to NIS 9 million will not be subject to class actions.
• For certain causes of action, before filing a motion the plaintiff must contact the business and give it 60 days to fix the issue. Without this, the motion will be dismissed.

My takeaway:
A class action is not always a question of who is right. Very often it is a question of how much it costs to see it through.
That is why the small defect nobody bothered to fix is sometimes the most expensive line on the balance sheet.

All articles and posts