I focus my practice on insolvency and debt arrangements, and I am regularly appointed by the courts as a trustee. I also advise directors and officers when a company runs into difficulty. What follows is general information only, and is not legal advice for a particular case.
When liability may arise under section 288
Section 288 of the Law deals with the liability of a director or a general manager who failed to act to reduce the scope of the insolvency. It does not automatically place all of the company's debts on the director. It allows the court, on the conditions set out in the section, to impose on the director or the general manager liability toward the corporation for damage caused to the corporation's creditors by the omission.
The main conditions that arise from the section are these:
- The person is a director or a general manager. As drafted, this is not a rule that applies to every officer.
- The person knew, or ought to have known, that the corporation was insolvent. Under section 2 of the Law, insolvency is a state in which the debtor cannot pay its debts when they fall due, or in which its liabilities, including future and contingent liabilities, exceed the value of its assets.
- The person did not take reasonable steps to reduce the scope of the insolvency.
- An order opening proceedings has been made in respect of the corporation, and the application is brought by the trustee or by the Official Receiver (the Supervisor of Insolvency and Economic Rehabilitation Proceedings).
Under section 288(d), liability under the section will not arise if the director or general manager proves that he or she relied in good faith, and that the reliance was reasonable, on information according to which the corporation was not insolvent. Under section 288(c), notwithstanding sections 259 and 260 of the Companies Law, a company may not exempt a director or a general manager from liability under section 288, and may not include in its articles a provision that allows that person to be indemnified for a breach of that duty.
What the Law treats as reasonable steps
Section 288(b) sets a presumption: a director or general manager is taken to have taken reasonable steps to reduce the scope of the insolvency if he or she took steps to assess the corporation's economic situation, and acted so that the corporation would take one of the following:
- Obtaining assistance from parties who specialize in the rehabilitation of corporations.
- Negotiating with the corporation's creditors in order to reach a debt arrangement with them.
- Opening insolvency proceedings.
This is a presumption, not an automatic exemption. Taking one of these steps does not by itself mean that liability will not be imposed, and failing to take one of them is not decisive on its own. In practice, the board should examine the company's financial position in real time, record the information it relied on, and consider in good time a rehabilitation effort, a debt arrangement, or the opening of proceedings, rather than continuing as usual while the deficit grows.
Personal guarantees, preferential transactions and other routes
Section 288 is not the whole picture. A director who signed a personal guarantee for a company debt, for example in favour of a bank or a supplier, may be sued on the guarantee even if insolvency proceedings have been opened for the company. That is a separate contractual route, and it does not depend on liability being imposed under section 288.
The Law also allows the court to set aside certain acts done before an order opening proceedings. Section 219 deals with setting aside an act that conferred a preference on a creditor, that is, an act that led to the payment of a debt to a creditor or to an improvement of that creditor's place in the order of payment, if it was done in the period fixed by the Law, at a time when the debtor was insolvent, and as a result that creditor would recover a larger part of the debt than would have been recovered in the proceedings. The period fixed in the section is three months before the date on which the application for an order opening proceedings was filed, and one year if the creditor is a relative of the debtor. The section has qualifications, including where adequate consideration was given, or where the act and the debt that was paid were in the ordinary course of business. Such a setting-aside is aimed first of all at the act and at the person who received the preference. It does not, by itself, place the company's debt on the director. That said, a decision to prefer one creditor over others, at a time when the company is already insolvent, may also be examined in other contexts.
Section 220 deals with setting aside an act that removes assets from the insolvency estate. Here too, the application and the conditions need to be examined on the facts of the case.
There are two further routes in Part H of the Law, which should be kept separate from section 288. Section 289 allows the court, at the request of the trustee or the Official Receiver and after an order opening proceedings, to order a corporate officeholder, or a person who was an officeholder, to compensate the corporation, to pay it, or to restore an asset to it, if a duty toward the corporation was breached in a way that gives rise to such a cause of action. For this section, "officeholder" includes, among others, an officer of the corporation, and not only a director or a general manager. Section 290 deals with fraudulent management: if the court finds that a person who was an officer knowingly took part in managing the corporation fraudulently in the period before the order opening proceedings, it may, at the request of the trustee or the Official Receiver, hold that person liable for damage caused to the corporation as a result, and disqualify that person from serving as an officer in any corporation for a period of up to five years.
What to do when the company is approaching insolvency
When there are signs that the company is struggling to pay its debts when they fall due, or that its liabilities may exceed the value of its assets, the board cannot wait for the picture to clear by itself. Without presenting this as a list of steps that produces a fixed legal outcome, these are directions that arise from the Law and from practice:
- Assess the company's economic situation in time, on the basis of current information, and not on a gut feeling or outdated reports.
- Record the discussions, the information that was presented, and the decisions that were taken.
- Consider approaching parties who specialize in the rehabilitation of corporations, and consider whether there is room to negotiate a debt arrangement with creditors, or to open insolvency proceedings.
- Be careful of selective repayment, or of giving security to one creditor, in a way that may confer a preference over other creditors.
- Be careful of transferring assets out of the company, of taking on new credit without a clear picture, and of signing personal guarantees without understanding what they mean.
- Remember that even if the business continues to trade, the point at this stage is not only to buy time, but to consider how to reduce the scope of the insolvency and protect the creditors' estate.
The role of the trustee
When the court makes an order opening proceedings in respect of a corporation, it appoints a trustee to carry out the proceedings, under section 33 of the Law. Under section 42, the trustee's role is to wind up the corporation, or to operate the corporation and work toward its economic rehabilitation, in each case in accordance with the order. In that role the trustee determines debt claims, acts to collect and manage the assets of the insolvency estate, and, if a winding-up has been ordered, also realizes the assets and distributes them among the creditors. Under section 43, upon the appointment, the powers vested in the corporation's organs and officers pass to the trustee, and the trustee uses them to the extent required to perform the role. The trustee acts on behalf of the court and is subject to its directions.
In the context of directors' liability, the trustee (and the Official Receiver) have a further role: they are the parties who may ask the court for relief under sections 288, 289 and 290, and who may ask for acts to be set aside under the provisions on the insolvency estate, including section 219. In plain terms, once an order opening proceedings has been made, the person who ran the company is no longer necessarily the person who runs the proceeding, and decisions taken before the order may be examined again.
Frequently asked questions
Does the company's limited liability always protect directors?
No. The company is a separate legal person, but there are routes in which a director or an officer may bear personal liability. One of them is section 288, which applies to a director or a general manager who did not take reasonable steps to reduce the scope of the insolvency. Other routes include a personal guarantee, a breach of duty toward the corporation under section 289, and fraudulent management under section 290.
To whom does section 288 apply?
The section applies to a director or a general manager. It is not drafted as a general rule for every officer. Other officers may still be exposed under other routes, including sections 289 and 290, and under company law.
If I took one of the steps in section 288(b), am I protected?
The Law creates a presumption that these are reasonable steps, if they were preceded by an assessment of the corporation's economic situation. That is not complete immunity. In addition, under section 288(d), liability under the section will not arise if good-faith, reasonable reliance on information according to which the corporation was not insolvent is proved.
Is a personal guarantee cancelled when insolvency proceedings are opened for the company?
Not necessarily. A personal guarantee is a separate obligation of the guarantor. The opening of proceedings for the company does not, by itself, cancel the guarantee. What can be recovered under the guarantee depends on the wording of the instrument and on the circumstances.
What is the link between a preference and a director's personal liability?
Section 219 allows the court to set aside an act that conferred a preference on a creditor, if the conditions in the section are met. The setting-aside is aimed at the act and at the preference that was given. It does not automatically place the debt on the director. Still, a decision to prefer one creditor at a time of insolvency may also be relevant to an examination of the director's duties under other routes.
What is the trustee's role vis-a-vis directors and officers?
The trustee is appointed when the order opening proceedings is made, conducts the proceeding in accordance with the order, and holds the powers of the organs and officers to the extent required for the role. The trustee may also, together with the Official Receiver, ask the court to impose liability under sections 288, 289 and 290, and ask that acts that harmed the insolvency estate be set aside.
The information on this page is general only, and is not legal advice or a substitute for it. Do not act on the basis of this information without obtaining legal advice tailored to the specific circumstances.